by Stephen Lawrence*

In the wake of my last post, search engine giant Google and the Associated Press (AP) reached an agreement allowing Google to return to hosting AP content. Did the floodgates then open to overwhelm my inbox with those “author: Samantha Critchell” Google News Alerts which I had previously set?
Not exactly.
During the full calendar week of February 14th – 20th, I received 18 separate alerts containing a total of 27 links. This was a slight improvement over the reporting of 16 alerts and 20 links for the previous period of January 19th – February 2nd. When broken down by source the pattern remains the same:
- ABC News led with 14 links linking back to AP material hosted on their parent site.
- Newspaper sites accounted for 10 more.
- While the remaining three were either foreign or with no hard-copy editions.
The print to web ratio for the prior period, as I found, was evenly matched this week.
- Five of the ten Google alerted newspaper articles had a corresponding print presence.
- The remaining articles were web exclusives.
One might have expected to see a greater surge of articles since this most recent “experiment” coincided with New York Fashion Week and Ms. Critchell is the AP’s fashion maven. Her subjects ranged from Marc Jacobs, Zac Posen, and Luca Luca to Naomi Campbell’s Fashion benefit for Haitian relief. (During the previous period, topics ranged from the Golden Globes to Vera Wang’s designs at previous Winter Olympics.)
A similar Yahoo! News search supplies only six newspaper stories along with a smattering of local TV sites, a couple of which overlapped with the Google Alerts coverage.
To date, our BurrellesLuce readers have located over 80 articles published during that week attributed to Samantha Critchell (this includes the five mentioned earlier). And, these are only the ones relating purely to Fashion Week coverage. There are an additional 100+ older articles which saw print in newspapers.
While there may well be a number of underlying factors at work here – ranging from other individual licensing agreements to spidering blocks – the raw totals are telling.
This week, we find an 8:1 disparity in Fashion Week coverage, or an 18:1 disparity in subject coverage for this print to web experiment.
For my purposes, this was but a simple experiment. But would you be willing to subject your client to such uncertainties knowing these possible results?
*Bio: A native of Mesa, Arizona, I graduated from the University of Arizona with a major in Near Eastern Studies. I began my career with BurrellesLuce in 1997 as a reader. As with most readers, I developed a special relationship with my assigned papers – those small town dailies and weeklies of the same flavor that my family had been employed in for two generations. Currently, I hold the position of quality assurance specialist, troubleshooting daily production issues. Outside interests include woodworking, and keeping my wife and dog happy. Twitter: BurrellesLuce; Facebook: BurrellesLuce




online survey of 1,000 millennial women, ranging in age from 22-35, who are employed full-time in the United States. (In the U.S., women will soon comprise half the workforce and Millennials are now one-third of the working population.)

